Tooth ‘disfigurement’ law suit without merit: Nestlé Waters

By Ben Bouckley

- Last updated on GMT

Tooth ‘disfigurement’ law suit without merit: Nestlé Waters
A law suit has been filed against US drinks giants Nestlé USA, Nestlé Waters and the Gerber Products Company, after a young girl claimed that fluoride in their products severely damaged her teeth.

Prosecuting law firm Nidel Law said that the plaintiff it represents, from Maryland, had suffered from dental fluorosis (permanent tooth disfigurement), and is seeking damages to cover ongoing dental work and pain and suffering. Her teeth are pictured.

Nidel Law and fellow law firm Paulson and Nace filed the suit on August 29, alleging that the “defendants marketed and sold these products, with no warning about the likelihood of damage to her [the girl's] teeth”.

Dental fluorosis

According the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), dental fluorosis is caused by ingesting fluoride before the age of 8.

Nidel Law said in a statement: “While many in the public may have heard the claims that fluoride prevents cavities, according to the CDC, the preventative benefits of fluoride are predominantly when it is applied topically (rather than ingested) to adult teeth, after the age of 8.”

Science thus showed, Nidel Law claimed, that when fluoride is ingested by people under the age of 8 “there is a significant risk of harm, while at the same time there is no benefit”.

The company added: “The defendants in this case knew that their products contained fluoride and actively marketed these products to children and to parents for the use in their children.”

“The defendants failure to warn of the risk of harm from these products is unacceptable.”

The products in question relevant to the case include Deer Park natural spring water with added fluoride, and Poland Spring natural spring water with added fluoride, both of which contain 0.8ppm of the chemical ion.

Product meets FDA standards

Nestlé's Carnation Good Start infant formula and Gerber baby food are also named in the complaint.

However, a spokeswoman for Nestlé Waters North America told the US media that the firm believed the suit to be “without merit”​.

Although Nestlé Waters sold a product labeled ‘with added fluoride’, it had levels of the chemical ion consistent with those established by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), she added.

But Nidel Law claimed that US guidelines on bottled water and fluoride were extremely limited, and the suit also accuses the companies of marketing fluoridated products to an age group that cannot benefit from it, placing them at risk.

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Uniting Flavor & Function in Dairy Beverages

Uniting Flavor & Function in Dairy Beverages

Content provided by Virginia Dare Extract Co Inc | 20-Feb-2024 | White Paper

As demand for functional beverages grows, dairy’s innate nutritional benefits and creamy sensory experience make it a compelling choice for consumers.

Replicate full sugar taste.

Replicate full sugar taste.

Content provided by ADM | 24-Oct-2023 | White Paper

Sweetening solutions and flavor technology must work in unison to successfully achieve sugar reduction targets.

Energy Drinks That Perform on Every Level

Energy Drinks That Perform on Every Level

Content provided by ADM | 18-Oct-2023 | Infographic

As the number of energy options for consumers continues to grow, best-in-class innovation allows your brand to stand out. From adventurous and fresh flavor...

Tagatose—a sweet way to reduce calories

Tagatose—a sweet way to reduce calories

Content provided by ASR Group | 04-Oct-2023 | Application Note

Introducing Tagatose - an excellent alternative to high potency sweeteners and sugar alcohols. Tagatose is a rare sugar that’s 90% as sweet as sucrose...

Related suppliers